22-year old Cam Newton out of Auburn was the #1 overall pick in the 2011 NFL Draft. But, he only started 1 year at Auburn and despite having great physical talent, he might not be ready to excel in the NFL mentally quite yet. Newton is without a doubt the Panthers’ QB of the future, but, I think it would probably be better for him to watch the first few games due to the lockout cutting a lot of practice time out. If Newton would have had a full training camp, I think they would have thrown him into the fire right off the bat. But, I think he would be overwhelmed by NFL defenses right now. The Panthers can’t afford to screw up Newton, so look for him to be holding a clipboard early in his career.
23-year old Jimmy Clausen looked overmatched last season but he’s the favorite to start the Panthers’ season opener at Arizona. Clausen played in 13 games (10 starts) as a rookie for the Panthers last year and he completed 157 of 299 passes (52.5%) for 1,558 yards with 3 TD passes and 9 INTs (58.4 QB Rating). Clausen also carried the ball 23 times for 57 yards (2.5 ypc) last year. The Panthers were 1-9 (10%) in games started at QB by Clausen last year. Clausen projects as Cam Newton’s long term backup but he will likely get the starting nod in Week #1. It’s up to him how long he will keep the starting job.
28-year old Derek Anderson was signed to give this group a veteran presence. Anderson played in 12 games (9 starts) for the Cardinals last year and he completed 169 of 327 passes (51.7%) for 2,065 yards with 7 TD passes and 10 INTs (65.9 QB Rating). Anderson also carried the ball 5 times for 25 yards (5.0 ypc) last year. Anderson has now played in 51 games (43 starts) in his first five years in the NFL and he has completed 756 of 1,436 passes (52.6%) for 9,148 yards with 53 TD passes and 55 INTs (68.8 QB Rating). Anderson has also carried the ball 76 times for 205 yards (2.7 ypc) with 5 TD runs so far in his career. Anderson is 18-25 (41.9%) as a starting QB so far in the NFL. Anderson has been to a Pro Bowl in his career but he often makes bad throws that result in pickoffs and his accuracy has never been too good in the NFL.
25-year old Tony Pike is going to have a hard time making the roster unless Newton, Clausen or Anderson gets injured. Pike played in 1 game off the bench for the Panthers last year and he completed 6 of 12 passes (50%) for 47 yards with 0 TD passes and 0 INTs (60.1 QB Rating).
PROJECTED GRADE FOR THE PANTHERS QBS IN 2011: D-